• 63
  • 378
  • 40
  • 97
756 SHARES

Henry Kissinger's Celebrated Legacy: Examining the Erosion of Achievements Following His Passing

Thursday, 30 November 2023 17:30 Opinion

"Henry Kissinger's Complex Legacy: Unraveling the Paradoxes of a Cold War Strategist"

In the realm of 20th-century politics, Henry Kissinger, the architect of US power dynamics, has left a legacy marked by both celebration and critique. As a symbol of American neo-imperialism, Kissinger, who recently passed away at the age of 100, was a Cold War strategist, US secretary of state, counsellor to 12 American presidents, and a figure accused of war crimes. Despite Enoch Powell's assertion that political lives inevitably end in failure, Kissinger stands as a notable exception, with a career characterized by multiple professional failures that concluded on a note of international regard.

A champion for American global hegemony, Kissinger played a pivotal role in reshaping imperialism with a post-colonial facelift. His pursuit of perceived national interests, irrespective of the costs borne by others, embodied a hard-eyed realpolitik that is now witnessing the unraveling of American global dominance. Yet, the three pillars of Kissinger's achievements – the opening to communist China in 1979, a less confrontational relationship with the Soviet Union, and the quest for common ground between Israel and the Arabs – rested on fragile foundations that eventually crumbled.

The 1972 maneuver that brought Richard Nixon to Beijing to meet Mao Zedong, known as "playing the China card," was initially hailed as a breathtaking feat, placing pressure on the Soviet leader, Leonid Brezhnev. However, post-revolutionary China reaped immense benefits, experiencing a rapid economic, business, and investment boom that contributed to its emergence as a global superpower. While it would be simplistic to blame Kissinger for China's current trajectory, characterized by aggression and expansionism, the parallels with President Xi Jinping, whom Kissinger met in July, are evident. As Kissinger's legacy undergoes scrutiny, the complexities of his influence on the geopolitical stage come to the fore.

"Kissinger's Legacy: Detente, Nuclear Arms Control, and Unintended Consequences"

Henry Kissinger's influence extended beyond his role as a Cold War strategist, leaving a lasting impact on detente with the Soviet Union and shaping nuclear arms control treaties under Nixon's Republican successors, Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush, both of whom sought his counsel. However, the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1989-91, a triumph celebrated by Western policymakers, led to unintended consequences, bringing humiliation to the Russian people. The failure to help Moscow build a prosperous democratic state and the perceived betrayal of Nato enlargement promises strained relations, contributing to the resentful resurgence of Russia under Vladimir Putin.

As Kissinger's world unfolded, the dynamics shifted, and present-day challenges emerged. Putin, well-versed in the "China card" trick, strategically aligned with Xi Jinping before the invasion of Ukraine in February the previous year. The summit meeting declared a "no limits" partnership, leaving the US diplomatically wrongfooted. China now presents a formidable challenge to US leadership and values globally, while Russia, fueled by bitterness and resurgent power, poses a threat to peace in Europe. Both, in their own ways, are legacies of Kissinger's maximalist thinking.

Turning to the Middle East, the illusory successes of American peace-making efforts, both under Kissinger and subsequently, come to the forefront. While Kissinger played a role in mediating an end to the Yom Kippur War in 1973, the fundamental conundrum of coexistence between Jews and Palestinians in a disputed land remains unaddressed after 50 years. The perception of American political one-sidedness favoring Israel, dating back to Kissinger's time in office, persists.

Kissinger's enduring presence in foreign policy debates makes him a unique witness to the conflicts, travails, and triumphs of the American century – the era of the US-dominated, post-1945 international order. As his legacy undergoes scrutiny, the unintended consequences and geopolitical shifts triggered by his actions come to light, leaving a complex tapestry of global repercussions.

"Kissinger's Legacy: Standing Against the Tide of Change"

Henry Kissinger, in many ways, appeared resistant to the changing tide of world affairs, defying the growing emphasis on national self-determination and human rights. While his contributions to detente and nuclear arms control are acknowledged, certain aspects of his legacy remain contentious. Notably, his support for the brutal military coup in Chile in 1973, which ousted the elected government of Salvador Allende, stands as a dark testament to the myopic and destructive American neo-imperialism of that era.

Kissinger's involvement in supporting violent cold war nationalist groups during proxy conflicts, such as Unita in Angola and the Contras in Nicaragua, as well as his role in propping up authoritarian regimes in Africa and the Middle East, reflected policies shaped by his thinking. The repercussions of such actions, echoing in Vietnam, where he is credited with helping to end the war, resulted in a broken and shattered country succumbing to totalitarian rule, rendering past sacrifices futile.

The haunting memory of the secret carpet-bombing of neutral Cambodia in 1969-70, under Kissinger's direction, remains a stain on his legacy. The indiscriminate strikes, claiming around 50,000 civilian lives, sparked accusations of war crimes, notably examined in Christopher Hitchens' book, "The Trial of Henry Kissinger."

As Kissinger assumed the role of an elder statesman in the subsequent decades, the horrors and failures of his past were often set aside. However, the question lingers: Was Kissinger a man of a different age, or has that age truly passed with him? Simon Tisdall, a foreign affairs commentator, invites reflection on the enduring impact of Kissinger's legacy and its implications for the present and future.

In reflecting on Henry Kissinger's complex legacy, the conclusion invites contemplation on whether his departure marks the end of an era or if the lingering shadows of his actions still cast a pall over the present. While Kissinger's contributions to global diplomacy and his role in shaping key geopolitical events are acknowledged, his support for authoritarian regimes, involvement in proxy conflicts, and decisions with devastating consequences are enduring points of contention. The hope is expressed that with Kissinger's passing, the age characterized by his pragmatic and often controversial approach has come to a close. Yet, the lingering impact of his geopolitical maneuvers prompts consideration of the lasting implications for the contemporary world and the ongoing pursuit of justice and human rights.

Next
The mother of a 6-year-old Muslim boy, who was fatally stabbed in what is believed to be a hate crime related to the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas