• 63
  • 378
  • 40
  • 97

Poppy Day Rituals: An Essential Antidote to Extremism in British Society

Tuesday, 14 November 2023 03:52 Opinion

"Silent Reflections: The Enduring Legacy of Remembrance in Shaping British Unity"

Once again, a poignant hush will descend upon Whitehall, Westminster, and the airwaves of the nation at 11 o'clock this morning, a welcome and solemn silence that transcends the cacophony of contemporary debates. Yesterday, as two minutes of tranquility briefly quelled the sharp arguments surrounding war, peace, protest, and prejudice, a profound truth emerged – Remembrance possesses a unique power to unite us, dispelling the illusion that clashes over this tradition can tear our society apart.

The Armistice of 11 November 1918 marked not an end to war but a formal ceasefire. The celebrations of peace had to await the 1919 Treaty of Versailles, culminating in Peace Day that summer, with a temporary cenotaph as its centerpiece. The anniversary of the November armistice was initially unplanned until the proposal of a two-minute silence at 11 am by the King and cabinet a week before. The "great stillness" struck a chord that resonated across the nation, evolving into a tradition that has endured for a century.

In 1920, George V unveiled the permanent stone Cenotaph, leading the national silence on Armistice Day. The choice of silence, in part, reflected the tumultuous times. A mass rally on the eve of the first armistice anniversary protested against leaving the dead in foreign fields, igniting debates that newspapers of the era stoked. Even a century ago, culture clashes over Armistice Day were evident, with differing perspectives on how to appropriately commemorate the occasion.

Despite expectations that the tradition might fade away, Remembrance has not only persisted but also gained significance. The frailty and diminishing numbers of veterans evoke a collective emotional response, ensuring that Remembrance transcends living memory. Contentious modern wars, such as those in Afghanistan and Iraq, have played a role in revitalizing Remembrance, mirroring its origins that spanned opinions on the necessity or futility of the Great War.

In the midst of these reflections, Remembrance stands not just as a ritual but as a testament to the endurance of unity, a thread that weaves through the complex tapestry of British society, providing a moment of shared reflection that surpasses political divides and resonates across generations.

"The Harmony of Remembrance: Uniting Diverse Narratives in Modern Britain"

The juxtaposition of yesterday's Palestine protest against the backdrop of armistice weekend was an unintentional collision of timing, seized upon to underscore a perceived culture clash within Britain. It appeared to pit two parallel worlds against each other – one of respect and tradition, the other of protest and dissent. Some even went so far as to frame it as a clash of civilizations, a confrontation between the established norms of the majority and the allegiances of ethnic and faith minorities.

In the wake of this clash, questions about the potential emergence of a religious war in Britain surfaced, echoing through the airwaves as populist figure Nigel Farage posed the query to his GB News audience. However, amidst these tensions, the observance of Remembrance provides a poignant counterpoint, offering one of the most robust foundations for shared identity in the diverse tapestry of modern Britain.

I, like many, wear my poppy not merely as a symbol of remembrance but as a tribute to the shared history of our contemporary, multi-ethnic society. The armies that fought in the two world wars were remarkably reflective of the Britain of the 2020s, boasting an ethnic and demographic mix that diverged significantly from the demographics of 1914 or 1940. The trenches saw service from individuals of various faiths – Christians, Jews, Hindus, Sikhs, and Muslims – fighting side by side.

The arrival of the Windrush in 1948 marked a pivotal moment in the narrative of a modern, multi-ethnic Britain. However, it's crucial to recognize that it represented a new chapter in a more extended historical context. The story of Commonwealth service, often forgotten in the 20th century, has experienced a resurgence in awareness in recent years. The commemorations during the First World War centenary from 2014 to 2018 significantly increased public awareness of Indian soldiers' contributions, yet knowledge of the 400,000 Muslims who fought as part of the Indian army remains comparatively lower.

Continuing to disseminate knowledge about the contributions of ethnic minorities, especially Muslims, within the Commonwealth has the potential to serve as a vital antidote to extreme voices of any ideology. By highlighting the rich tapestry of contributions from diverse communities, we counteract the narratives that seek to promote a clash of civilizations within British society. Witnessing how students across the country respond to this history, questioning its absence from the curriculum, underscores the importance of fostering awareness and understanding for a more inclusive and harmonious future.

"Amidst Tensions, Embracing the Unifying Power of Remembrance"

In a week marked by the unfortunate amplification of tensions by those tasked with defusing them, the solemn act of laying wreaths by the King and representatives from various realms offers a poignant moment to reassert the unifying potential of Remembrance. As we stand together in silence this morning, it is crucial to recognize that Remembrance holds the power to bring us together, bridging divides when we fully grasp the comprehensive history of service and sacrifice that binds us in collective reflection.

Sunder Katwala, the director of British Future and author of "How to Be a Patriot," highlights the need to leverage Remembrance as a force for unity in these challenging times. The act of remembering, grounded in an understanding of our shared history, has the capacity to transcend discord and reaffirm our common humanity.

In the face of current tensions, this call to embrace the unifying power of Remembrance serves as an invitation for collective reflection, urging us to rise above divisive narratives. As wreaths are laid and silence falls, let it be a reminder that the shared act of remembrance has the potential to unite us, fostering a sense of shared identity and shared destiny.

If you have reflections or opinions on the issues raised in this article, we welcome your contributions. Submit a letter of up to 250 words to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. to join the conversation and contribute to the ongoing dialogue on unity and remembrance.

"In Conclusion: A Call for Unity Through Remembrance"

As we stand in silent reflection this morning, the act of laying wreaths by the King and representatives from diverse spheres becomes a symbolic testament to the enduring power of Remembrance. In a week marred by heightened tensions, the solemnity of this ritual invites us to reassert the unifying potential embedded in the full history of service and sacrifice.

Sunder Katwala's poignant reminder, urging us to embrace Remembrance as a force for unity, resonates as a call to transcend the divisions that too often characterize our times. The act of remembering, grounded in an understanding of our shared history, becomes a collective bridge that spans across differences and reaffirms our common humanity.

In this conclusion, the invitation is extended to all to participate in this shared act of remembrance, recognizing its capacity to unite and foster a sense of shared identity. As wreaths are laid in silence, may it serve as a poignant reminder that, in the face of discord, Remembrance stands as a beacon, illuminating the path towards unity and a shared destiny for all.

The mother of a 6-year-old Muslim boy, who was fatally stabbed in what is believed to be a hate crime related to the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas